• 0 Posts
  • 28 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 16th, 2023

help-circle


    1. Tax carbon (and equivalents)
    2. give back all carbon tax to all citizens, equally
    3. Increase tax linearly over time, and let folks and business plan their transition predictably.

    This will incentivize people to demand affordable transportation, transition to alternatives, get low income citizens a reason to not oppose increased cost of living. Big consumers have to pay, low consumers will pay a little but get more back.

    Check out Citizens Climate Lobby.








  • That’s a fairly good analogy, and it did made me this over a bit more. I agree that it would be weird if they put captions behind an extra fee. I suppose captions are more part of the “standard” offering historically so I would definitely just expect it to be included whereas timed lyrics is not something I’d expect by default. But I do an acknowledge that this could shift, especially as this feature enable deaf users to enjoy music. Hopefully Spotify can take the critique and find a good compromise that helps this user group. I just don’t think they thought to do this to squeeze money out of deaf users. I’m guessing it’s more of an unfortunate side effect.


  • It’s unfortunate and I can empathize with the user but I don’t see it as obvious that this specific need should be catered to, for free. It’s primarily a music service and lyrics is an additional service to enhance the experience, apparently at the paid-tier. It’s not so expensive that it’s inaccessible to the average user, if music with timed lyrics is an important part of their life.






  • I’ll play the uniformed devils advocate here:

    1. Is the GPL license enforceable?
    2. And if so, I assume “derivative” will still subjective to some degree. Where do we draw the line between derivative and non-derivative?

    I’m torn about my personal opinion about copyrights and software licensing in general. I think the main problem is the huge power imbalance between people and corporations, not so much the fact a company analyzed a bunch of available data to solve programming problems.

    They don’t copy the data and sell it verbatim to others which would be a legal issue and in my mind also a moral issue, as they don’t add any additional value.