• 9 Posts
  • 868 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 12th, 2022

help-circle






  • Where on the Disc did you get ‘god-given external conditions’ from that?

    In the premise and in the presented alternative. As you noticed, the boots, while being literal in the story, are also a metaphor, but for a metaphor on the broad topic as poverty and affluence, it’s exremely reductive, especially for someone who is not a medieval cop with a meddle-age crisis of nihilism and rampant alcoholism (for whom it’s understandable) but a XXI century reader. It does not present anything else for you to make it an universal theory to proclaim with smugness. It’s also untrue because price don’t necessary, or even that much often, equal quality.

    Also Vimes was a cop and a lib, regardless what he babbled to himself, his job and purpose was to keep the status quo. And Pratchet, however good his books are was also a lib and his thoughts about revolution never came even an inch further than the usual liberal propaganda about revolution eating its children, lesser evil is dope and status quo is good, what he promoted was a old bankrupted “capitalism with human face” and other liberal ideals. Just he was intelligent enough to place his stories in the medieval like world where the capitalism is only emerging and this is still undeniably progressive.

    By “not to be taken seriously” i meant that Pratchet was not a 10 year old and even in his liberalism knew society, politics and economics are much more complcated than to make universal theory based on “price = quality”














  • Haven’t seen any prominent lib even use violent rhethoric in connection with pointing out Trump’s dangerous plans for his second term, so I was surprised you bring up stochastic terrorism.

    That’s precisely how stochastic terrorism works, the big wigs never straight up call for it to have their hands clean just in case, for that they have their tabloids, their agitators, their media heads, their internet trolls. And btw Biden did said they need to put Trump into the bullseye (though he most likely didn’t meant it literally, but on the other hand he promised to get rid of Nordstream back in the day and it happened).

    I agree that democratic processes have little to do with US politics these days, but are you suggesting you can promote democratic values with anything outside living them (not that US politician do that, but in principle).

    In principle i do but i don’t see liberal democracy as desirable version of it due to it being in service of the small minority of capitalists and their stooges exploiting workers, and as such the system works exactly according to its values. I just think those real values behind that system are abhorrent.

    And it shouldn’t matter where I’m from. The disaster that is the US empires fall is of global interest.

    What SUPAVILLAIN said. If you’re not part of the abovementioned minority or their stooge you should be dearly interested in end of the US empire.