Except the Federation is very much not equal. There’s plenty of genetic variation within species and a much larger variation between species. Vulcans live hundreds of years and have telepathy, humans die after just one hundred and are brain-blind. Bashir was born with severe genetic defects. Geordi was blind, and then he could see better than baseline. There are differences in fundamental capabilities everywhere.
Genetic engineering would allow those advantages to be shared by everyone. It annoys me how hypocritical the Federation is about this issue.
@FaceDeer@startrek Modern Trek has *really* pushed both the opposition to genetic enhancement and the prohibition of sentient AI. I suppose it is kinda in keeping with the “humanism” of the source material, but it seems like a blinkered view of the future. (I contrast it with the similarly post-scarcity Culture novels, where both biological modification and artificial Minds are common.)
Started the first book. Just finished the chapters Clear Air Turbulence. I was hooked from the prologue!
It also occured to me, I haven’t read much scifi. I watch a lot of scifi, I read a lot of fantasy. I haven’t read much sci-fi, so it’s kind of fun that it’s something new to me that I’d never really considered was missing until now. Thanks for the rec!
Except the Federation is very much not equal. There’s plenty of genetic variation within species and a much larger variation between species. Vulcans live hundreds of years and have telepathy, humans die after just one hundred and are brain-blind. Bashir was born with severe genetic defects. Geordi was blind, and then he could see better than baseline. There are differences in fundamental capabilities everywhere.
Genetic engineering would allow those advantages to be shared by everyone. It annoys me how hypocritical the Federation is about this issue.
@FaceDeer @startrek Modern Trek has *really* pushed both the opposition to genetic enhancement and the prohibition of sentient AI. I suppose it is kinda in keeping with the “humanism” of the source material, but it seems like a blinkered view of the future. (I contrast it with the similarly post-scarcity Culture novels, where both biological modification and artificial Minds are common.)
Haven’t heard of culture. Looking for a new book series to read. Is good?
Yes! Very good. Ian M Banks
I’ll check it out! Thanks!
Started the first book. Just finished the chapters Clear Air Turbulence. I was hooked from the prologue!
It also occured to me, I haven’t read much scifi. I watch a lot of scifi, I read a lot of fantasy. I haven’t read much sci-fi, so it’s kind of fun that it’s something new to me that I’d never really considered was missing until now. Thanks for the rec!
Well said, that is my take as well. There a difference between equality and everyone has the same capabilities and potential