For me it’s Deus Ex Mankind Divided. I played the original when it was new but barely remember it and I owned shadow war and never got into it.
However Human revolution blew me away. I loved that game so much. I still think about it and actually am making this post because I finally started cyberpunk last night and got human revolution vibes like crazy.
However I bought mankind divided on my birthday when it released. Happened to be right around the same day. I turned it on, walked a few steps and turned it off. For whatever reason I’ve never turned it on again.
The story is very strong in Witcher 3. One of the reasons I played was because I was excited about Open World in the Witcher Universe, and ended up loving it because of the heart-touching story.
Just a thing, if you get it, get the edition with all dlcs, goes usually for way too cheap during sales, and the dlcs are even better than the main story.