Polling catchments where Indigenous Australians form more than 50% of the population voted on average 63% in favour of the voice

Australia’s voice to parliament Polling catchments where Indigenous Australians form more than 50% of the population voted on average 63% in favour of the voice

  • TWeaKEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    You mention Wadeye, but the article also says this:

    Some regions in Queensland, where only 31.3% of the state’s population voted yes, showed a similar break away trend for communities with a high Indigenous population.

    High indigenous population, yet lower than the overall vote for the nation. The article glosses over how many polling regions this covers.

    I don’t doubt that the claim is likely true. I just don’t think they’ve done any sort of statistical analysis to actually support their claim. The article just makes a statement, then lists off numbers as if it all lines up. But there are big gaps and strong reasons to doubt the assumption, and yet the article states it as if it is fact.

    The style of writing is as if they’re writing an article about an academic paper, but they haven’t actually got an academic paper behind it.

    • RedReaper@infosec.pub
      2·
      1 year ago

      I think you’re misunderstanding the quote (or I’m misunderstanding you). That quote is supporting the same trend indicated in Wadeye. The 31.3% refers to QLD as a whole, not the ATSI dense communities specifically.

        • RedReaper@infosec.pub
          2·
          1 year ago

          I spent way too much time yesterday going through a full seat here in NSW comparing each polling location to the census data for that location, so I’m not going to do that all again for the entirety of QLD.

          However, I did have a look at the QLD LGAs with the highest % ATSI populations and got the following results

          I think that’ll be the closest sort of data we can get to an idea of the QLD ITAS support for the voice

          • TWeaKEnglish
            2·
            1 year ago

            Nice one! So Woorabinda is the outlier.

            Were there really only a couple hundred votes in each area though?

            • RedReaper@infosec.pub
              2·
              1 year ago

              Yeah, communities with ATSI population % that high tend to be pretty small after all, so polling places in those communities aren’t going to have a massive number of votes.

              All the results for each polling centre can be found here. The places I used as an example were across several different